This quest is a continuation of the mission And You Will Know the Truth in Red Dead Redemption. In this guide, we will describe its detailed walkthrough. After getting out of the car, watch the cutscene, saddle your horse, and head to Cochinay with the company following the indicated marker. Upon arrival, wait for the gate to explode and storm the camp with Dutch's men. Kill anyone who might get in your way.
Move further to reach the village where there will be even more opponents. Try not to get hit by bullets. After dealing with all the bandits, run to the gate marked on the mini-map to hear the captain's instructions. Your task is to protect the agents while they set up dynamite near the gate. Once inside, you will see Dutch behind a machine gun.
First, deal with his entourage, and then shoot the lamp located near the bandit to start a fire.
The Dutch will start to flee. Pursue him, making your way through the mine to the cliff's edge. Upon catching up with him, listen to his monotonous speech, after which Dutch will decide to jump down himself.
Watch the cutscene, from which you will learn that your wife and son are at the ranch in Beecher's Hope, after which you will be rewarded with +250 points to the Fame parameter and +125 points to the Honor parameter.